Amazon Counterfeiting: How to Protect Your Brand

For Amazon sellers, few threats are as damaging as counterfeiting. Imagine this: your brand is thriving, sales are increasing, and positive reviews are pouring in. Then, suddenly, your listing is flooded with 1-star reviews. Customers are complaining about issues you know don’t exist in your product. The cause? Counterfeit items infiltrating your Amazon listing through the platform’s fulfillment system.

This article breaks down how Amazon’s system can expose sellers to counterfeiting and how you can safeguard your business.

Understanding Amazon Fulfillment Options

When selling on Amazon, you can choose between two fulfillment methods:

  1. Self-Fulfillment:
    • The seller ships directly to the buyer.
    • Orders come with a seller-issued invoice, not Amazon’s.
    • No “Prime” badge is associated with the listing.
  2. Fulfilled by Amazon (FBA):
    • The seller ships inventory to Amazon’s warehouses, and Amazon handles order fulfillment.
    • Orders include the “Fulfilled by Amazon” label and often carry the “Prime” badge.

Most high-volume sellers rely on FBA for its convenience. However, FBA’s fulfillment system comes with a major flaw—comingling inventory—that facilitates counterfeiting.

How Amazon’s Comingling Fuels Counterfeiting

Amazon pools inventory from multiple sellers who list under the same ASIN (Amazon Standard Identification Number). For example, if several sellers are offering Bose headphones under a common ASIN, Amazon will group their inventory into a shared pool.

When a buyer places an order, Amazon pulls from this common inventory without verifying which seller provided the product. While this simplifies logistics, it creates an opening for counterfeiters to introduce fake goods into the supply chain.

The result? A legitimate seller could unknowingly have a counterfeit product shipped under their name. Negative reviews from these counterfeit goods then tarnish the original seller’s reputation.

Opting Out of Comingling

Sellers can opt out of comingling by adjusting their FBA settings before shipping inventory to Amazon:

  1. Go to Fulfillment by Amazon profile settings
  2. Navigate to FBA Product Barcode Preference
  3. Select Use the manufacturer barcode to track inventory

Once inventory is comingled, it cannot be separated. Taking this step early can help minimize counterfeiting risks.

Case Study: The Hijacking of Abe’s Abacuses

Let’s say Honest Abe sells a private-label product, Abe’s Abacuses, and enjoys steady sales and glowing reviews. Enter Crooked Carl, a counterfeiter who lists fake Abe’s Abacuses at a lower price.

Here’s what happens next:

  • Carl’s counterfeit products are shipped to Abe’s customers.
  • Carl might even win the Buy Box, becoming the default seller for Abe’s Abacuses.
  • Negative reviews from Carl’s fake products pile up on Abe’s listing.

Even if Abe removes Carl’s listing, the damage is done—his product’s reputation is tainted by 1-star reviews.

The Solution: Amazon Brand Gating

For private label sellers like Abe, Amazon Brand Gating is the most effective defense against counterfeiting.

Brand Gating is available to sellers enrolled in the Amazon Brand Registry. It requires all new sellers attempting to list under your brand to receive your explicit approval. This proactive protection prevents counterfeiters from listing fake products under your ASIN and hijacking your listings.

Protect Your Brand Today

Amazon’s comingling system and the threat of counterfeiting make it crucial for sellers to take preventive measures. Enrolling in the Amazon Brand Registry and securing Brand Gating are essential steps for safeguarding your business.

If you’re ready to protect your brand from counterfeiting, Leonov Trademark Law offers an E-Commerce Trademark Package tailored to Amazon sellers. Contact us today to learn how we can help secure your brand’s future.

Posted in